Conformal Coating
Comparison Guide
The following guide is only general in nature and serves as a broad
comparison of strengths and weaknesses.
ACRYLIC
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Ease of rework
- Simple drying process
- Good moisture resistance
- High Fluorescence level
- Ease of viscosity adjustment
|
Solvent Evaporation
- High VOC potential
- Difficult to maintain viscosity
- Requires close monitoring of solvent concentration, hence
creates a 2-part scenario
- Flammability
- High probability of reversion under temperature and humidity
stress conditions
|
|
Heat Cure
- Cure is dependent on thickness
- Component mass affects time and temperature of cure process
- Susceptible to cure inhibition
- Shrinkage (3% - 10%), potential for damaging fragile (e.g.,
glass) components
- Should be used with caution for low temperature components
|
|
UV Cure
- One component coatings require accurate application
material to avoid shadowed areas
- Two part systems require meter mix equipment
- Some coatings are more difficult to rework
- UV Intensity and Wavelength effects cure
- Some secondary cure mechanisms require heat
exposure
|
EPOXY
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Useful to about 150ƒC [302ƒF]
- Harder durometer, abrasion resistance
- CTE closer to epoxy PCB substrate
- Higher T g
- Good dielectric properties
|
Solvent Evaporation
- Higher chloride contamination potential
- Process intensive, difficult to maintain viscosity, complex
mix ratios
- Potential for high stress during temperature cycling conditions
- Difficult to rework
- High probability of reversion under temperature and humidity
stress conditions
|
|
Heat Cure
- Cure is dependent on thickness
- Component mass affects time and temperature of cure process
- Selective coating quality (edge definition) could be impacted
- Shrinkage (3% - 10%), potential for damaging fragile (e.g.,
glass) components
- Should be used with caution for low temperature components
|
|
UV Cure
- One component coatings require accurate application
material to avoid shadowed areas
- Two part systems require meter mix equipment
- Some coatings are more difficult to rework
- UV Intensity and Wavelength effects cure
- Some secondary cure mechanisms require heat
exposure
|
|
Catalyzed
- Cure inhibition
- Short work life
- Contamination sensitive
- Difficult to rework
- Pungent odor
|
POLYURETHANE
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Good dielectric properties
- Good moisture resistance
- Solvent resistance
- Less reversion potential
- Abrasion resistance
|
Solvent Evaporation
- Moisture affects cure rate and desired properties
- Long complete cure time (up to 30 days)
- Health and safety concerns
- Potential for high stress during temperature cycling conditions
- High probability of reversion under temperature and humidity
stress conditions
|
|
Heat Cure
- Cure is dependent on thickness
- Component mass affects time and temperature of cure process
- High VOC potential
- Reacts violently with presence of water
- Should be used with caution for low temperature components
|
|
UV Cure
- One component coatings require accurate application
material to avoid shadowed areas
- Two part systems require meter mix equipment
- Some coatings are more difficult to rework
- UV Intensity and Wavelength effects cure
- Some secondary cure mechanisms require heat
exposure
|
SILICONES
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Stable over wide temperature range (in
general, -40ƒC to
200ƒC)[104ƒF to 392ƒF]
- Flexible, provides dampening and impact protection
- Good moisture, humidity, and UV/sunlight resistance
- High dielectric strength
- Low surface energy to enable effective penetration under
components
|
Room Temperature Vulcanization (RTV)
- Requires humidity (minimum 20% RH) to cure and only intermittent
solvent resistance
- Low abrasion resistance
- Short pot life
- TCE is ~300-350 ppm/ƒC
- If proper house keeping is not followed, there is a potential
for cross contamination
|
|
UV Cure
- One component coatings require accurate application
material to avoid shadowed areas
- Potential for cure inhibition
- Low abrasion resistance
- UV Intensity and Wavelength affects cure
- Some secondary cure mechanisms react with moisture,
this can cause spray valves to become clogged
|
|
Catalyzed (Addition)
- Low abrasion resistance
- Potential for cure inhibition
- Adhesion may be difficult
- Only intermittent solvent resistance
- If proper house keeping is not followed, there is a potential
for cross contamination
|
POLY-PARA-XYLELENE C, D, N
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Excellent uniformity regardless of part
geometry ‚ no pinholes,
fillets, or bridging
- Chemical inertness/barrier properties ‚ insoluble
in organic solvents, acids, or bases, with very low permeability
rates
- Minimal added mass and low outgassing
- Biocompatibility allows uses in many medical applications
- Low environmental impact process
|
Vapor Deposition Polymerization
- Parts are processed by batches in a vacuum chamber, not
an in-line process
- Masking required for no-coat areas
- Coating removal and rework generally requires specific equipment,
abrasion/micro-blasting most common technique
- Limited UV resistance and operating temperature
limit, around 120ƒC [248ƒF] in the presence of oxygen
- Cannot be doped
|
FLUORINATED POLY-PARA-XYLELENE
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Excellent uniformity regardless of part
geometry ‚ no pinholes,
fillets, or bridging
- Chemical inertness/barrier properties ‚ insoluble
in organic solvents, acids, or bases, with very low permeability
rates
- High temperature stability (450ƒC [842ƒF])
and increased UV stability
- Low dielectric constant, 2.28
- Low environmental impact process
|
Vapor Deposition Polymerization
- Parts are processed by batches in a vacuum chamber, not
an in-line process
- Masking required for no-coat areas
- Coating removal and rework generally requires specific equipment,
abrasion/micro-blasting most common technique
- The coating is deposited at a rate slower than the conventional
poly-para-xylelenes
- Requires special deposition equipment different than that
for the C, D, and N poly-para-xylelene varieties.
|
AMORPHOUS FLUOROPOLYMER
|
5 Strengths of Coating
Type
|
5 Weaknesses of Cure
Type
|
|
- Low dielectric constant
- High glass temperature
- Low surface energy
- Low water sorption
- Good solvent, oil and common acid resistance
|
Solution Deposition
- Requires special liquids for polymer swelling
- Limited solubility which limits film thickness
- May require glass temperature anneal
- Requires special surface treatment for greatest adhesion
- Poor resistance to some acids and alkalines
|
|
Vacuum Deposition
- Requires pressure of 10 Torr ‚ 5 Torr [0.193 PSI ‚ 0.097
PSI] or less
- May require glass temperature anneal
- Requires special surface treatment for greatest adhesion
- Poor resistance to some acids and alkalines
- Poor abrasion resistance
|
|